Lawsuit challenging Indiana voucher program to proceed despite setback

Good for the Indiana State Teachers Association and the plaintiffs in Meredith v. Daniels for deciding to continue their legal challenge to the Indiana private-school voucher program.

The ISTA announced Friday that it would go forward with the lawsuit despite Marion Superior Court Judge Michael D. Keele’s denial of an injunction that would have blocked the program from taking effect.

“This week’s ruling was only the very beginning of the litigation in this case,” said ISTA vice president Teresa Meredith, a Shelbyville teacher. “It’s important to Indiana and its public schools that we continue to pursue this challenge, and we will pursue it before the trial court and higher levels of the court system.”

The plaintiffs, who include teachers, parents, and clergymen, may or may not prevail. But at least we will find out whether Article 1, Section 6 of the Indiana Constitution means what it says: that “no money shall be drawn from the treasury, for the benefit of any religious or theological institution.”

Keele, in a thorough and clearly written decision, denied the request for an injunction because, he said, the plaintiffs didn’t provide evidence that they were likely to prevail on the merits of the case. He said the voucher program doesn’t provide money directly for religious institutions – parochial schools – because the vouchers go to parents, who decide where to spend the money for tuition.

But as the ISTA points out, the claim that vouchers give parents a choice about their children’s education is bogus when 97 percent of schools participating in the voucher program are religious schools.

As Scott Elliott reported in the Indianapolis Star, all 45 Marion County private schools that signed up for vouchers are religious schools; about three-fourths are Catholic schools. That’s pretty much the pattern across the state – except that Gary, one of the state’s largest cities and home to some of its lowest-performing public schools, has only two voucher schools: a Christian academy and a Seventh-Day Adventist elementary school.

Of the more than 250 schools statewide that will accept vouchers, maybe a half-dozen are not religious institutions. And some of those charge tuition that is far beyond what a low-income family can pay, even with the help of a $4,500 state voucher.

In Indianapolis the choices are St. Barnabas, St. Christopher, St. Pius X, St. Philip Neri, etc. … To paraphrase a well-known conservative, that’s not a choice, it’s an echo.


1 thought on “Lawsuit challenging Indiana voucher program to proceed despite setback

  1. The effect of the vouchers, intended or not, is to benefit a religious institution. Thus, it seems the courts must focus on the “effect,” regardless of the intent.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s